Are Low P/E Stocks Value Traps?

I used to chase low P/E stocks thinking they were bargains, until I learned that cheap usually means broken. Sometimes a stock looks like a steal on paper, but that low number might be hiding a lot of problems.

Let me break down what I've seen and learned about these value traps, and share a little wisdom from Warren Buffett on what to do if you already own a wonderful business.

A company's Price/Earnings ratio is its stock price divided by its earnings per share, showing how much investors pay for each dollar earned.

Recognizing a Value Trap

First off, a low P/E ratio isn't automatically a green light. Take Verizon for example. Its P/E is about 9.6, which is way lower than the S&P 500 average of 20, yet its stock price has dropped 33 percent over the last five years.

That got me wondering if that low number really meant a bargain or just a warning sign.

Then there's the issue of earnings. Even if a stock appears cheap, falling or stagnant earnings are a big red flag. I noticed that Verizon's quarterly earnings-per-share (EPS) dropped from $1.25 in 2019 to $0.78 in the most recent quarter. A business with declining profits justifies its' cheap valuation.

Sometimes it isn't just about one company—the whole industry can be crap. In the communications space, not only Verizon but also AT&T and Charter have been underperforming. Meanwhile, innovative players like Nvidia have posted impressive earnings (They're last quarter had 110% YoY growth).

And don’t be fooled by a high dividend yield. Take Walgreens, for example: it once was offering a 9 percent dividend, but recently suspended payments because of funding issues. A high yield might look attractive, but it can hide deeper problems that cause the stock to fall:

Lastly, management matters a lot. I learned that a shift in leadership style can change the game. Look at Apple: under Steve Jobs, it was all about breakthrough innovation and growth. Now, under Tim Cook, the focus has shifted more to preserving cash and buying back shares. When a company switches from a visionary founder to a caretaker mode, it’s a sign that its growth engine might be slowing down.

Hold on to Wonderful Businesses

Now here’s where Buffett’s advice really hits home. He once said, "If you own a wonderful business, the best thing to do is keep it. All you're going to do is trade your wonderful business for a whole bunch of cash, which isn't as good as the business, and you got the problem of investing in other businesses, and you probably paid a tax in between."

For me, that means if you already have a business that’s fundamentally strong and growing, don't sell it just to chase a stock that looks cheap or flashy.

The temptation of a low P/E should never override the value of a great business that has solid fundamentals.

Final Thoughts

What I've learned is that a low valuation doesn't always signal a bargain. Usually, those low numbers hide weak earnings, an out-of-favor industry, or management that’s lost its spark.

Before jumping in, dig deeper into the company’s fundamentals. And if you already own a wonderful business with solid growth, take Buffett’s advice and hold onto it instead of swapping it for a so-called bargain that might end up being a trap.

The link has been copied!